View all stories

An Agreement on Plastics Fails

In today's edition of This Week in Climate, we look at the plastics treaty that wasn’t.
Abigail Bassett
Dec 16, 2024 10 min read
Share this post

Early in December, more than 200 countries gathered in Busan, South Korea to finalize a way to curb global plastic pollution. After two years of discussions, the meeting in Busan was pivotal to getting a plan in place, but Saudi Arabia and Russia blocked the agreement, and the delegates left without curbing plastic production.

It was the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC-5) and that aimed to finalize the treaty, which would have limited plastic production and added chemical regulations by the end of 2024. Significant disagreements and a massive influx of big oil lobbyists and interests led to a deadlock, pushing discussions out to sometime in 2025, with no firm dates.

It’s a significant blow to climate change efforts, as plastic pollution is skyrocketing. A study from September noted that the globe creates more than 57 million tons of plastic pollution each year. That number is expected to skyrocket by 2040 when the world will produce an estimated 637 million tons of plastic per year, a 60% jump over current levels. Here's what happened and why the agreement broke down.

The Treaty

In 2022, the world's nations agreed that a global treaty was needed to tackle the issue of plastic pollution, with a particular focus on the impacts on the marine environment. Originally, the delegates determined that the treaty should be completed within two years because of the urgency of the issue. The proposed Global Plastics Treaty, which was under negotiation and backed by the United Nations, aimed to address the escalating crisis of plastic pollution through a legally binding international framework.

Delegates wanted to achieve various goals that included a cap on global plastic production, phasing out single-use plastics (think things like plastic forks and knives), regulating the use of hazardous chemicals in plastics production, improving recycling and reuse programs around the globe and offering technical and financial support for developing countries to help reduce plastic waste and pollution.

The negotiations took place over two years, and at the end of the day, countries could not agree to a final treaty. Russia and Saudi Arabia, two of the largest oil producers (among other oil-producing nations) scuttled the deal.

Oil and plastic are linked in a number of ways. First, oil is a key component of plastic production, and according to the United Nations, more than 98% of single-use plastic is produced from petrochemicals made from oil and gas.

The feedstocks, or the raw materials used to create plastics, come from the refining of crude oil and natural gas. Big oil has long pinned its hopes for growth on the increasing demand for plastics around the world, and the world’s top seven producers of plastic are large oil firms, including ExxonMobil and Sinotec. Plastic manufacturing currently accounts for around 12% of the oil consumption around the world.

Why Did the Deal Fail?

The treaty failed for a number of reasons, but the main reason was that big oil countries, like Russia, Saudi Arabia, India, Iran, and Kuwait, opposed changing the voting process to ratify the treaty. According to PBS, the treaty requires that proposals win a unanimous vote to make it into the treaty. For this particular treaty, some of the member countries wanted to change the process to a majority vote so that the deal wouldn't fall apart, but oil-rich countries opposed the change. The process ended up being paralyzed as a result. It didn't help that oil lobbyists outnumbered the host delegation by more than 30%.

Additionally, Saudi Arabia and Russia opposed the deal because they said that negotiations around caps on global plastic production and curbs on the hazardous chemicals used in plastic production fell outside the deal's scope, arguing that the focus should be on recycling and improved plastic collection instead. The Russian delegates argued that the curbs on plastic production were economically motivated.

African nations like Ghana, which have struggled with severe plastic pollution, decided that the final treaty had been so watered down that they would rather leave the treaty unfinished than leave with a less effective solution.

“We want a treaty that will be able to solve it,” Sam Adu-Kumi, Ghana’s lead negotiator, told PBS in an interview. “Otherwise we will go without it and come and fight another time.”

Why Plastics Matter: The Wider Implications

Plastics are a pillar of our modern world. They’re found in everything from food packaging to car bumpers and so widely used that plastics have even begun to be found in our bodies, rock formations, even the air we breathe. Thanks to tremendous plastic pollution and global use, plastics are literally everywhere.

The world is more than half a century on from Dustin Hoffman’s famous scene in the The Graduate, in which his neighbor pitches him on a future career with in one word: "Plastics." That line has proven to be prophetic. Since the 1950s, plastics have played a major role in the global economy, trade, and more. In fact, according to UN estimates, more than eight billion tons of plastic have been produced globally, while less than 10% has been recycled.

The production of plastic releases large amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, and oil companies have been looking for a way to offset weaker demand for their goods and materials as the EV transition takes hold. When plastics are inevitably discarded, they break down into smaller and smaller particles, which are increasingly penetrating human and ecological systems and wreaking havoc on the environment.

According to Bloomberg, “Plastic was responsible for 1.8 billion metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions in 2019, according to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. That’s 3.4% of the global total, more than the percentage of CO2 contributed by the aviation sector or emissions from all the rice grown worldwide. And plastic’s share is set to increase in coming years. Researchers project that the emissions from plastic will exceed 2.5 billion metric tons by 2050 if the current pace of growth and manner of production continue.”

Just days after the treaty fell apart, Coca-Cola, the largest known (branded) plastic polluter, announced that it revised its climate goals and moved away from its former plastic and pollution goals. Rather than reducing its use of virgin and single-use plastic, the company says it will focus on the use of recycled materials in its bottling. By 2035, the company aims to increase the use of recycled plastic in packaging to 30 to 35 percent and "help ensure the collection of 70 to 75 percent of the equivalent number of bottles and cans introduced into the market annually." That's a significant shift from its original plans to reduce the "use of virgin plastic derived from non-renewable sources by a cumulative 3 million metric tons from 2020 to 2025," and package 25 percent of its drinks in refillable or returnable packaging by 2030.

While there’s no hard date for the UN to resume negotiations on the plastic treaty, discussions are tentatively planned for sometime in 2025.

New climate jobs

Check out some of the latest featured jobs below. If you don't see anything that speaks to you, you can always go to Climatebase to explore thousands of other opportunities.

Recheck

“Recheck is a first-of-its-kind identity verification platform and system of record dedicated to accelerating the energy transition by building transparency and trust in the home efficiency industry. Backed by leading industry investors and partners and led by a team of proven founders and operators (Mixpanel, HipChat, Notarize, and Ohm Analytics), Recheck has quickly gained market traction and is poised for ...”

  • Customer Operations & Support Lead (Hybrid · Boston, MA, US)


HData

“HData is the energy industry’s leading provider of regulatory data solutions. Our AI-powered software platform provides compliance, analytics, and intelligence capabilities that help utilities, regulators, advocates, and service providers modernize time-intensive and outdated methods of working with regulatory data. By using technology to reduce manual, burdensome tasks for regulatory professionals, HData supports the energy industry in moving toward greater efficiency, ...”

  • Marketing Manager (Remote)


Private Energy Partners

“PEP has been established to provide the Quinbrook group with enhanced capability in project origination, development, asset management and revenue optimisation. Projects developed or supported by PEP are intended to be dedicated for future investment by Quinbrook Infrastructure Partners via its managed funds. Our three primary areas of focus are: Utility scale renewables, with a focus on solar and battery ...”

  • Data Engineer (Hybrid · Pasadena, CA, US)
  • Energy Analyst - Global Storage Team (Hybrid)


Equilibrium Energy

“Equilibrium Energy is a well-funded, Series A clean energy startup backed by some of the most prominent institutional investors in climate. We are building a digital native power company operating at the intersection of grid variability, market volatility, economic optimization, commercial structuring, and risk management, across the end-to-end power value chain. Our mission is to accelerate our collective path to ...”

  • Research Software Engineer (Sr/Staff) (Hybrid · Remote · Unit...)
  • General Interest (Hybrid · Remote · Cali...)
  • Quantitative Analyst (Staff / Sr Staff) - Power Markets (Hybrid · Remote · Cali...)
  • Research Scientist (Staff / Sr Staff) - Power Markets (Hybrid · Remote · Cali...)
  • Machine Learning Scientist (Staff / Sr Staff) - Power Markets (Hybrid · Remote · Cali...)


Station A, Inc.

“Station A is a technology company reimagining how clean energy is bought and sold. We're a remote-first company with team members across the USA and an office in San Francisco, CA. By combining proprietary technology and a team of experts, we help commercial real estate owners and occupants take swift action on their climate goals in the most cost-effective and transparent ...”

  • Energy Solutions Engineer (Hybrid · Remote · New ...)


ClimateAi

“About ClimateAi ClimateAi is on a mission to climate-proof the economy while aiming for zero loss of lives and livelihoods. We use AI to predict the risks of climate change to physical assets, water resources, and biodiversity. Then we generate actionable insights that help stakeholders build strategies for their operations, supply chain planning and regulatory disclosures. We are a fast growing ...”

  • Applied AI Scientist (Remote · United States)
  • Executive Assistant (In-person · Santiago d...)
  • Sr. Front End Engineer (Hybrid · Remote · San ...)
  • Principal Engineer (Hybrid · Remote · San ...)


RE-volv

“RE-volv is a climate justice organization that helps nonprofits in underserved communities across the country go solar while raising awareness about equitable climate solutions and training the next generation of clean energy leaders. Mission RE-volv empowers people and communities to invest collectively in renewable energy Vision We envision a world where people are thriving in communities powered by clean energy Our Theory of Change We believe ...”

  • Development Director (Hybrid)


Cambio

“Hi - we're Leia and Steph, co-founders of Cambio, software to help commercial real estate companies and their corporate tenants decarbonize their buildings. We do this by empowering them with data, specifically carbon emissions analytics and AI-based retrofit recommendations. We were former commercial real estate investors with 14 years of aggregate experience at Goldman, KKR and Oxford Properties / OMERS. We ...”

  • Building Engineer (Remote · United States...)
  • Customer Success Lead (Remote · United States...)
  • Enterprise Sales Lead / Account Executive - Real Estate (Remote · United States...)
  • Enterprise Sales Lead / Account Executive - SaaS (Remote · United States...)


Interstate Renewable Energy Council

“IREC is a nonprofit working toward a 100% clean energy future that is reliable, resilient, and equitable. Our mission is to build the foundation for rapid adoption of clean energy and energy efficiency to benefit people, the economy, and our planet. ...”

  • Director - Codes & Standards (Remote · United States)
  • Program Manager – Workforce Development (Hybrid · Remote · Unit...)


Presto Charging

“We believe that access to reliable and affordable charging is the key to unlocking mass electrification and fighting climate change. At Presto, we are building a software platform to power magical charging experiences for fleets, mobility providers, and businesses. For our charging partners, we strive to set in motion a positive flywheel of business demand and network utilization, helping expand ...”

  • Software Engineer (Platform) (Remote · Oakland, CA, US)


Sesame Solar Inc

“Sesame Solar is decarbonizing disaster response. We design and make Mobile Nanogrids powered by solar, green hydrogen, (optional small wind turbines) and battery storage with Essential Services Inside such as communications, clean water, refrigeration, medical assistance and more. Designed to be towed by electric trucks, Sesame Nanogrids have EV charging on board to provide a 100% fossil-fuel free Solution for extreme ...”

  • Director of Manufacturing (In-person · Jackson, M...)


Zitara

“Zitara Technologies builds battery management software for companies with large deployments. Customers across industries (EVs, satellites, renewable energy storage) rely on Zitara's cloud-ready embedded solutions for advanced battery management that precisely predict and manage the charge of every vehicle or fleet asset. With a precise charge plan, enterprises can minimize downtime, maximize the longevity of their battery systems, increase safety, ...”

  • Senior II Data Engineer | Platform Software (Hybrid · Remote · Cali...)
  • Senior Field Applications Engineer (Hybrid · San Francisco...)
  • Staff Simulation Software Engineer (Hybrid · San Francisco...)


ev.energy

“ev.energy set up in 2018 to make electric vehicle charging greener, simpler and cheaper. We do this by ingesting real-time data from various sources which, partnered with our smart-charging algorithm, means we align charging sessions with energy from renewable sources, helping drivers avoid charging their car at peak times using fossil-fuel derived energy. EVs are growing in popularity; a third of ...”

  • Sales Director - UK & EU (Hybrid · Remote · Unit...)
  • Business Development Manager - Utilities (Hybrid · Remote · Unit...)


SINAI Technologies

“SINAI is a San Francisco-based technology company focused on transforming the way companies price, analyze and reduce carbon emissions around the world. We are passionate about technology and the environment, and our mission is to engage companies and governments to include carbon analysis in their entire operations, transforming the way they interact with their own business, their value chain, and ...”

  • Sales Director (Remote · United States)
  • Fullstack Software Engineer (Remote · Brazil)
  • Product Designer (Remote · Brazil)


Prime Coalition

“Prime Coalition is a 501(c)(3) public charity that partners with mission-aligned investors to support extraordinary companies that combat climate change, have a high likelihood of achieving commercial success, and would otherwise have a difficult time raising adequate financial support to scale. We believe that catalytic capital* holds a critical key to unlocking commercial products and services that can help avoid catastrophic ...”

  • Manager of Executive Office (Remote · United States)
  • Director, Partnerships (Remote · United States)


Twelve

“We're Twelve, the carbon transformation company—a new kind of chemical company that makes things from air, not oil. Our breakthrough technology eliminates emissions by transforming CO2 into critical materials, products and fuels. When it comes to addressing climate change, carbon isn’t our nemesis. To the contrary, we see carbon as the element of change. Carbon isn’t just the building block ...”

  • Principal Process Engineer (Remote · United States)
  • Senior EHS Specialist (In-person · California...)
  • Senior Engineering Director, Plant Development (Hybrid · Remote · Unit...)
  • Future Opportunities at Twelve (Remote · Berkeley, CA, US)


Tierra Climate

“To reach Net Zero, the U.S. needs between 200-400 gigawatts of grid-scale energy storage by 2050, requiring over $1 trillion dollars in investment. Tierra Climate is an innovative technology company dedicated to unleashing the decarbonization potential of grid-scale energy storage. We’re pioneering a new category of environmental attributes for energy storage that will enable sustainability-minded companies to financially support emissions-reducing ...”

  • Optimization Research Scientist (In-person · Houston, T...)


Boundary Stone

“BSP is the leading climate change government affairs firm working at the intersection of technology, finance, and policy. ...”

  • Manager-Legislative Affairs (Hybrid · Washington, D...)


Liminal Insights

“Our core belief is that better data and analytics in battery manufacturing can catalyze the EV transition by significantly improving battery cost, quality, and reliability. We are working towards a clean energy future in which everyone who wants an EV can afford one. ...”

  • Staff Solutions Engineer (Hybrid · Emeryville, C...)


Found Energy

“Found Energy is building clean energy delivery platforms capable of replacing fossil fuels for heavy industries ranging from aluminum smelting (3% of global CO2 emissions) to fertilizer production (2% of global CO2 emissions) to maritime shipping (3% of global CO2 emissions). Building off technology developed at MIT that enables metallic aluminum to split water, our energy delivery systems safely generate ...”

  • Electrical Engineer Technician (In-person · Boston, MA...)
  • Mechanical Engineer Co-op (In-person · Boston, MA...)
  • Materials Engineer Spring Co-op (In-person · Boston, MA...)
  • Electrochemical Engineer Spring Co-op (In-person · Boston, MA...)
  • Chemical Engineer Spring Co-op (In-person · Boston, MA...)
  • General Application (Remote · Boston, MA, US)

The Author

Abigail Bassett